15.Researching and Evaluating Practice
-
Research in healthcare and physiotherapy is conducted and implemented to bring improvement to clinical practice and improve patient care. It is essential for discovering effective treatments and making sure that as autonomous professionals we are using the optimum treatment for the appropriate patient needs (1). Therefore, as a physiotherapist that will utilise research as per the CSP Code of Members’ Professional Values and Behaviour which states “members should consider relevance of new developments, research findings, evidence and measures of effectiveness” being able to collect, analyse, synthesis information to evaluate current practice and generate new understandings is a core underpinning skill in practice. By upholding this I will also be demonstrate the NHS value of commitment to quality of care for all patients (2).
Being involved with research and evaluation of practice is something as a student I feel I have been apprehensive to engage with as believe that sometimes it is something it is not my place to discuss in practice due to my limited experience. However, my service improvement project gave me some exposure (PDSA) and I believe demonstrates skills I have learnt around designing, planning conducting and managing research. As part of the project I designed a measurement plan – this identified timescales, root causes, measurement tools and definitions which are all required for a well-designed research plan. I also put clear aims in what improvement I wanted to observe that are SMART to be able determine if a change was observed. This further demonstrates my behaviour and knowledge into the use of methods of enquiry to collect and interrupt data in order to address problems or issues arising from practice and inform future practice. Although I was unable to complete and fulfil the project after I discussed the project with my senior to reflect and evaluate the effectiveness the project may have. Whilst I was not able to disseminate – the proposed project itself outlined on Service Improvement Poster demonstrates an awareness of methods used to disseminate findings to a professional specialist audience..
At the beginning of the degree I did not have a broad knowledge of research methodology, tools or processes used so this was an area of huge development for me. As part of the evaluation of research process it is important to critically appraise the research. My awareness of crticial appraisal tools I learnt in second year include, CASP tool or PEDRO which further consider strengths and weaknesses of articles. Additionally, to ensure that I complete broad systematic research I completed a PICO to ensure a variety of search terms were considered. The application of these tools and methods can be seen in my Professional Enquiries SE222 Essay; an assignment which helped to embed the use of a range of tools and methods I have used for a research project and critically appraising research- as seen in the evidence I completed a PICO, literature search, prisma diagram, used critical appraisal tools and discussed my findings of two articles both quantitative and qualitative.
In my second year, I completed a Complexities of MSK module in which I choose an injury, being achielles tendinopathy, and produced a poster and leaflet which was then presented. These information tools were designed for patients without a medical background to give information regarding the injury and potential cause, the management and how a physiotherapist may support, whereas the presentation was given to Physiotherapy professionals. During this presentation I explained my choices for the inclusion of research. Justifications included: where the information came from, i.e. NICE guidelines or the British Medical Journal, the type of research being RCTs or systematics reviews and highlighting that in some of the research there were gaps in the detail. Whilst these was a challenging assignment in terms of having the present my justifications of literature whilst also understanding the injury itself- I believe the module was key in my learning development of clinical reasoning with the involvement of research. This evidences my knowledge of critically evaluating the research and communicating the outcome of the research and then sharing and disseminating the findings with others- in this case specialists and non-specialists- thus including the ability to adapt my communication. Furthermore, in this project I believe I demonstrated skills in promoting the practical and professional applications of the work. I believe my Complexities MSK Poster, Complexities Leaflet and Feedback evidence the discussed above.
Also, as part of this degree, I have been working on a Dissertation into the effects of swimming training on children- within this project I researched an area that I was interested in, then from current guidelines and research addressed where there was a gap in this area- from discussing the current literature base in the area I formulated a research proposal, detailing the research methods, tools used and detailed the ethical considerations required for the research to take place. Both the Service Improvement project and dissertation project challenged me in terms of having to consider what would be ideal in the terms of completing research but also being realistic in what is possible in a time scale. As my dissertation research proposal involved paediatrics ethical considerations were key assuring I was aware of all consideration around researching with children- this is evidenced in my Research Proposal.
Researching and evaluating practice skills will be something which is continued in my practice to ensure I am an evidenced based practioner- as upheld by the HCPC. Research is crucial within healthcare to ensure continuous development of quality practice and is something that without realising is continuously happening around us; for example: within the last year much evidence has been collected around the benefits of proning for Covid-19; initially due to pressures this was low quality evidence however, retrospectively has been analysed in more detail (3). Whilst conducting and designing research may not be within my immediate future in my career- the skills of evaluating research to make further informed decision in my practice will be frequently used.
References:
1- NHS Northern Care Allience, 2020, Why is Research Important?, [online], viewed: 22nd December 2021, accessed: https://www.pat.nhs.uk/education-and-research/why-is-research-important.htm
2-NHS, 2021, Values of the NHS Constitution, [online], viewed 25th October 2021, viewed: https://www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/working-health/working-nhs/nhs-constitution
3-Tatlow, C., Heywood, S., Hodgson, C., Cunningham, G., Conron, M., Ng, H., Georgiou, H. and Pound, G., 2021. Physiotherapy-assisted prone or modified prone positioning in ward-based patients with COVID-19: a retrospective cohort study.Physiotherapy,.