14.Practice Decision Making
In physiotherapy practice decision making is a frequent daily skill required for patients based on their presentation, clinical information, and evidence with further collaboration from the MDT driving the health-related decisions (1). As autonomous healthcare practioners, physiotherapists are expected by the HCPC to be able “draw on appropriate knowledge and skills to inform practice” – this includes gathering appropriate information, use appropriate assessment techniques and use research, reasoning and problem-solving skills to determine appropriate actions with appropriate knowledge (2) . Therefore, as a physiotherapist student I have developed knowledge and skills to collect and interpret information to demonstrate my clinical reasoning for treatment and management.
Throughout the various placements, I have observed how different places present their hospital documentation and have been exposed to searching through these to collect the information needed prior to my assessment. Collecting information from a variety of sources relevant to decision making situations I believe I first demonstrated on my first placement in orthopaedics. Prior to seeing a patient I attend MDT board rounds which informed me of patient medical update, cognition and pain, read the notes to gather post-operative guidance, surgery and weight-bearing status and then check their NEWS score which indicates their cardiovascular stability- with this information I would then go to speak to the patient gather how they were feeling and use this to formulate an initial mobility session. I believe my clinical reasoning form (placement 1) and Orthopaedic SOAP notes indicates how I considered all aspects of information to practice decision making with a routine approach. Similarly, my skills to process and analyse the information collected is also evidenced within my Respiratory Clinical Reasoning Form, with these forms, I utilise my finding and analyse them to form a treatment plan ensuring all factors are considered. This was based on a respiratory patient with queried aspiration pneumonia.
At times, with orthopaedic trauma patients who were identified to have a difficult surgery, I would also use some specialised approaches to gather information in terms of looking at x-ray. This skill is something I wish to keep continuing learning in the future and believe with frequency of looking at x-rays will improve. From this orthopaedic placement I believe it hardened a good habit of note checking, NEWS score and nurse or doctor clearance to see a patient which I have since continued in practice. Additionally, an alternative more specialised approach I aimed to learn about on my stroke placement was CT scans- I aimed to use this to improve my clinical reasoning in understanding the region of the brain that was damaged to further support my understanding of impairments. Not only did I try to regularly look at CTs on placement I used online resources also for learning; this is evidenced by CT Head Images Learning.
The process and analyse of information collected occurs daily in physiotherapy practice. Information is gathered from reading notes and the initial moment you meet a patient based on their observation and level of engagement in physiotherapy. In neurophysiotherapy on my 4th placement, every new patient with a queried stroke would have a complete neurological assessment. This was a skill I developed well on this placement, having to complete the neurological assessment, interept the findings and document this to formulate patient goals. I believe this assessment and documentation in Stroke Neuro Ax demonstrates my processing and analysing information collected which would then being used to make further decisions in treatment and initial goals. On placement I would complete this assessment in both routine low level impairment patients and in complex ensure stroke patients and would therefore have to be adaptable to the patient to collect and analyse information from both complex and predictable situations. This skill of doing this in the future will be carried over into all areas of physiotherapy- respiratory, musculoskeletal care of the elderly, etc.
The process of decision making in physiotherapy is crucial during discharge planning which is an emerging key role of a physiotherapists in an acute setting with the awareness of mobility, safety and functional ability. Discharge planning itself involves collecting information from a variety of sources from all members of the MDT, drawing conclusions to make informed decisions considering the patient functionally, cognitively and their social environment with their relatives (1). Unfortunately, the Covid -19 has impacted the health and care services with community hospital rehabilitation cut and community teams reallocated to support other services more challenges arose as my time as a student. However, on my care of the elderly placement I managed some complex patient and when discharge planning how I would have to consider the best for the patient with their impairments, ability, comorbities as well as the discharge options I had. Case Study 2 is a case study where throughout discussed the factors I had to consider when coming up with a discharge plan- from this experience I learnt that whilst I may have wanted to consider an option where a patient would get the most optimal rehabilitation, it was not the best place for him mentally; this demonstrates my holistic management of a patient whilst considering their wishes and ability to collect information relevant to a decision making situation and process and analyse it. Difficult Discharge Decision further demonstrates my ability to reflect on the situation- I discuss how I am aware that it is the best decision yet how it was a personal learning experience that will develop my decision making in the future. Whilst I am aware of how emotions should not influence my practice and in this case they didn’t, at times this can be challenging but I believe with experience and patient milage this will become more manageable.
Throughout placements I have developed clinical reasoning both verbally and written in my notes. A way to have evidenced my thought process and share this with others I have completed clinical reasoning forms. This encourage me to break down the patient I have in front of me, ensure I am utilising and collecting information from a variety of a sources and critically analyse the information and situation in order to provide clinically reasoned patient management. Clinical reasoning forms I believe evidence that I am to critically evaluate the decision-making process- these clinical reflecting forms have improved my skills doing this on placement as evidenced by Placement Feedback re: clinical reasoning and reflection which demonstrates my reflective ability. Furthermore, demonstrating my skills and behaviour around critically evaluating my decision making is Case Study 4 – in which I outline how I felt I handled the patient and what I would do different next time; being alternative decisions in their management in that I would utilise a this is me booklet and use an outcome measure which I did not do frequently in this care.
*Clinical Reasoning Forms can be seen in mandatory evidence.
References:
1-NHS England, 2021, Reducing long stays: where best next campaign? [online], viewed: 23rdDecemeber 2021, accessed: https://www.england.nhs.uk/urgent-emergency-care/reducing-length-of-stay/reducing-long-term-stays/
2-Health and Care Professions Council, 2022, The standards of proficiency for physiotherapists, [online], viewed: 23rd December 2021, accessed: https://www.hcpc-uk.org/standards/standards-of-proficiency/physiotherapists/ ,